Next in the course catalog: Chicks 101?
I’m glad to see more people talking about young men’s troubles getting through college, and I’ve been following with interest stories about the admissions bar being lowered for male students, so that universities can preserve gender balance on campus. I spent this morning at the annual conference of the Association of Public and Land-Grant Universities, where panelists discussing the “American Male Imperative” talked about guys’ disconnect at college. Males are less likely to graduate, we know that, but according to the panelists, they are also less likely to take advantage of advising and counseling services, to participate in study abroad and other enrichment programs and to appreciate the constructivist and group-work approaches to academics that were designed specifically to engage students.
Among other things, the panelists suggested a reconsideration of the value of the lecture, more gender-themed housing and dude-centered majors. Hmmm. Beyond the fact that this is fodder for way too many easy, unfunny jokes, what is missing, for me, is a discussion of how we got here. Certainly the genesis of “the boy problem” is societal as much as educational. Could the rise of a child-centered culture and helicopter parenting have empowered girls to take charge of their lives at the same time it absolved boys of ever having to do so? Just thinking out loud.
Among other things, the panelists suggested a reconsideration of the value of the lecture, more gender-themed housing and dude-centered majors. Hmmm. Beyond the fact that this is fodder for way too many easy, unfunny jokes, what is missing, for me, is a discussion of how we got here. Certainly the genesis of “the boy problem” is societal as much as educational. Could the rise of a child-centered culture and helicopter parenting have empowered girls to take charge of their lives at the same time it absolved boys of ever having to do so? Just thinking out loud.


2 Comments:
Bleck! "Group work!" Constructivism! This stuff is death to boys who just want to *do* something!
Women for the most part are the ones teaching elementary school boys in crowded little classrooms where the kids aren't able to run and play. My own son could add triple digit numbers upon entrance to kindergarten, but was he recognized for his abilities? Nope. He was given a circle and triangle to cut out (and he can't do this well, even now) and suspended repeatedly in the first week alone because he couldn't keep his hands to himself or "attend to task." And no way they would want to promote a jumping bean to second or third grade, particularly one who qualified for special-needs preschool the year before because of his inability to attend to the test.
Thankfully, he is now homeschooled and entering fifth/sixth grade math (Singapore/Teaching Textbooks) at the age of eight. But his handwriting is not the best. Likely if he had stayed in ps his handwriting would be neater (he would doubtless receive OT) and he'd have figured out how to stop jumping while reading, but his math would languish.
I'm not saying that "Mom's precious snowflake" is so way smarter than anyone else. I'm just saying that males can be more difficult to teach in some ways and have uneven skills. They are more difficult to fit into a regimented class schedule and are less socially mature than girls when they're younger as a group.
Please read this link:
http://www.philly.com/inquirer/opinion/20091109_The__reform_math__problem.html
It is about autism and math, but is also (I believe) applicable to "boys and math."
Mrs. C's comments remind me so much of my son Steve and my daughter Linda. Steve was turned off in kindergarten and never was turned back on. We were wiser when it was Linda's turn and sent her to a different kindergarten. The difference was and still is (35 years later).
Mrs P
Post a Comment
Considerate comments are welcome. Uncivil remarks will be deleted. Anonymous comments -- including those unaccompanied by the author's first and last name -- are not permitted.
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home